PDA

View Full Version : Well at Least the PS3 Leads in Something


lUnAtIc
05-27-2007, 10:30 PM
Link:

http://www.sonyprotectiongroup.com/?/content/view/25/1/


Reality Check: Quality of Games for Current Consoles Written by ColinMcP Saturday, 26 May 2007


http://i13.tinypic.com/4xyotps.png
Often you will hear from gamers from one console group or the other "Your system has no quality games". In the last 6 months this has been true for owners of PS3, we hear it all the time. SPG has set out to investigate these claims.



To attempt impartiality on this topic we have used the ratings of MetaCritic.com. MetaCritic is owned by C|net and only rates games where their exists a minimum of 5 reviews from known, quality review sites. MetaCritic then averages these scores out.



The above chart then dispays the percentage of reviewed games with scores over 80% and under 50% for each console.



Reality Check Consoles (PS3/X360/PS2/Wii):


Of all current consoles the PS3 has the HIGHEST percentage of games rated over 80%.



Of all current consoles the X360 has the LOWEST percentage of games rated under 50%



The Wii has the LOWEST percentage of games over 80% and the MOST under 50% of any console.



Reality Check Handhelds (PSP/DS):



The PSP has the HIGHEST percentage of games over 80% and the LOWEST percentage under 50%



Conclusions:


Consumers are willing to forgo quality games to get a better price. Both the DS and Wii are providing the lowest cost of entry to video gaming but offering the least in terms of game quality vs other consoles.

SPG will check back on this topic from time to time.

SoccerHooligan
05-27-2007, 11:32 PM
Interesting...

When I reviewed Meta Critic PS3 had 14 out of 54 games at 80% or higher
360 had 52 out of 188

Its possible my brain is friend from accounting... But I could have sworn that puts the average at
PS3: 26% (25.93%)
360: 28% (27.66%)

In games that are above average (>75 or rather the green) it is similar:
PS3: 22/54= 41% (40.74%)
360: 84/188= 45% (44.68%)

AND finally.... In games rated at 50 or lower (red) it is set at this
PS3: 3/44=7% (6.8%)
360: 8/188= 4% (4.25%)

If theres something wrong with my math please tell me as I better stop doing my accounting HW then....

Otherwise they are pulling numbers out of their arse...

I decided to run the Wii calculations too.... This they were at least CLOSE to right...

(>80%)
4/55= 7% (7.27%)
(>75)
10/55= 18%(18.18%)
(<50)
9/55=16%(16.36%)

Their computations are as questionable as a sexual predator taking small kids on a "mission trip"

Then again I wouldnt expect less from a site such as that.... :P

SoccerHooligan
05-27-2007, 11:57 PM
Interesting...

When I reviewed Meta Critic PS3 had 14 out of 54 games at 80% or higher
360 had 52 out of 188

Its possible my brain is friend from accounting... But I could have sworn that puts the average at
PS3: 26% (25.93%)
360: 28% (27.66%)

In games that are above average (>75 or rather the green) it is similar:
PS3: 22/54= 41% (40.74%)
360: 84/188= 45% (44.68%)

AND finally.... In games rated at 50 or lower (red) it is set at this
PS3: 3/44=7% (6.8%)
360: 8/188= 4% (4.25%)

If theres something wrong with my math please tell me as I better stop doing my accounting HW then....

Otherwise they are pulling numbers out of their arse...

I decided to run the Wii calculations too.... This they were at least CLOSE to right...

(>80%)
4/55= 7% (7.27%)
(>75)
10/55= 18%(18.18%)
(<50)
9/55=16%(16.36%)

Their computations are as questionable as a sexual predator taking small kids on a "mission trip"

Then again I wouldnt expect less from a site such as that.... :P

Crap, wouldnt let me edit my response again....

Well here are the links to the Metacritic site in case someone wants to check my math....

360
http://www.metacritic.com/games/xbox360/scores/
PS3
http://www.metacritic.com/games/ps3/scores/
Wii
http://www.metacritic.com/games/wii/scores/

SeSsIoNz 07
05-28-2007, 01:18 AM
F***


That crappy consel


Fin.

Torenko
05-28-2007, 01:44 AM
Well... even if the stats are correct, uhm...

Well, I still love my 360 more. =D

SoccerHooligan
05-28-2007, 04:04 AM
Well... even if the stats are correct, uhm...

Well, I still love my 360 more. =D

If they actually showed the computations I would be a little less skeptical

SeSsIoNz 07
05-28-2007, 06:27 AM
Gin n Toniques taste like shazzz.

im drinkin one now.

DutchMike
05-28-2007, 08:56 AM
It's accounting like this that eliminated Enron..........:p

SoccerHooligan
05-28-2007, 07:53 PM
It's accounting like this that eliminated Enron..........:p

Haha exactly :P